Fire up the grill and get the coals nice and hot. If using an oven, preheat to 425ºF (218ºC).
Pierce the eggplants several times with a fork or long skewer. (Trust us, you do not want to skip this step unless you want to experience the aftermath of an eggplant explosion!)
Place eggplants on the grill or in the oven with the pierced side facing up. Cook for 45-60 minutes until the eggplants have deflated and are soft and caramelized all the way through. If cooking on the grill, expect a soft top and a brittle, charred bottom.If using the oven, the bottom may not be as crispy, but that's normal. Let the eggplants cool: Place them in a bowl, cover with aluminum foil, and let them steam and cool for at least 30 minutes. This can be a break point—feel free to refrigerate them for a few hours or overnight. (Pro tip: Cold eggplant is less likely to make the tahini taste bitter. Shaun learned the hard way when he tried to rush this step!) Reserve the liquid: After removing the foil, you'll see a brown liquid at the bottom of the bowl. This concentrated smoky eggplant flavor is gold—save it for the next step.
Separate the skin: Slice off the tops and cut the eggplants in half. Scoop out the soft interior with a spoon and discard the skin. A few bits of skin left behind won’t hurt the flavor, so don’t worry if some sneaks in.
Whip the tahini: In a food processor, combine tahini, garlic, lemon juice, paprika, salt, and the reserved eggplant liquid. Blend until smooth and doubled in volume. If the mixture looks dry, add ice water 1 tablespoon at a time until smooth.
Blend in the eggplant: Add the eggplant and blend until you reach your desired texture—chunky for more bite, or smooth for a velvety finish.
Taste and adjust: Adjust salt to taste and blend again for a few seconds.
Enjoy! Serve this smoky, creamy dip with warm pita, fresh veggies, or whatever you love to dip. We promise—it’s heavenly!